Critics unglued by government's advice to buy duct tape
Everyone knows that for the last week, American's have been urged to stock up on emergency supplies, such as bottled water, batteries and food. And everyone knows that in addition to the emergency kit supplies, the government has been suggesting that we buy plastic and duct tape to seal our homes in the case of a chemical attack. Mind you, I've been one of the first to laugh about everyone rushing out to buy duct tape and plastic, mostly because I live in the middle of Iowa and the idea that there would be an attack here in the middle of the country seems a little far fetched to me. None the less, there have been higher than usual sales of duct tape and plastic in and around Cedar Rapids and Iowa City. At the same time, I've also wondered whether or not said plastic would really cut the mustard in the face of a serious chemical or radiological attack, and the answer is probably not.
However, despite my own criticisms, I think it's ok that the government is encouraging us to at least do this much preparation. In the end there is probably very little that we can do to protect ourselves from the rumored attacks, so why not do what we can that will make us feel at least a little better about the situation. The amount of preparations people have to do to feel comfortable are going to be different for everyone. For instance, Jeff and I haven't done anything. However, if we lived in a bigger city we probably would have at least bought batteries for the radio and a little extra food. (even though our friends think our fridge is ready for a nuclear winter every day of the week.) On the other hand, a coworker of mine received a phone call this morning from her ex-husband in Salt Lake City. He wanted to make sure they had spoken and were on civil terms should the world end this weekend.
What's irritating me is that there are so many experts running to the media discounting the governments advice because they believe it's not going to be effective. As Harold Schaitberger, general president of the International Association of Fire Fighters said : "I mean, duct tape and plastic? Where's the good air coming from? How's it going to be recirculated? Beyond the fact that we already know, for nerve gas and other elements, the plastic is totally ineffective. I think it was done just to give people a sense of `Everything will be OK,' and to give them a sense of confidence." Seriously folks, We all know that the whole buying plastic thing really isn't going to save your life in a major attack. But isn't peace of mind worth something?
Other than buying plastic and duct tape there really isn't anything that most American's can do to protect themselves, so what's the issue with the government at least encouraging an action that could make you feel a little more comfortable, maybe allow you to sleep a little better at night.
Everyone knows that for the last week, American's have been urged to stock up on emergency supplies, such as bottled water, batteries and food. And everyone knows that in addition to the emergency kit supplies, the government has been suggesting that we buy plastic and duct tape to seal our homes in the case of a chemical attack. Mind you, I've been one of the first to laugh about everyone rushing out to buy duct tape and plastic, mostly because I live in the middle of Iowa and the idea that there would be an attack here in the middle of the country seems a little far fetched to me. None the less, there have been higher than usual sales of duct tape and plastic in and around Cedar Rapids and Iowa City. At the same time, I've also wondered whether or not said plastic would really cut the mustard in the face of a serious chemical or radiological attack, and the answer is probably not.
However, despite my own criticisms, I think it's ok that the government is encouraging us to at least do this much preparation. In the end there is probably very little that we can do to protect ourselves from the rumored attacks, so why not do what we can that will make us feel at least a little better about the situation. The amount of preparations people have to do to feel comfortable are going to be different for everyone. For instance, Jeff and I haven't done anything. However, if we lived in a bigger city we probably would have at least bought batteries for the radio and a little extra food. (even though our friends think our fridge is ready for a nuclear winter every day of the week.) On the other hand, a coworker of mine received a phone call this morning from her ex-husband in Salt Lake City. He wanted to make sure they had spoken and were on civil terms should the world end this weekend.
What's irritating me is that there are so many experts running to the media discounting the governments advice because they believe it's not going to be effective. As Harold Schaitberger, general president of the International Association of Fire Fighters said : "I mean, duct tape and plastic? Where's the good air coming from? How's it going to be recirculated? Beyond the fact that we already know, for nerve gas and other elements, the plastic is totally ineffective. I think it was done just to give people a sense of `Everything will be OK,' and to give them a sense of confidence." Seriously folks, We all know that the whole buying plastic thing really isn't going to save your life in a major attack. But isn't peace of mind worth something?
Other than buying plastic and duct tape there really isn't anything that most American's can do to protect themselves, so what's the issue with the government at least encouraging an action that could make you feel a little more comfortable, maybe allow you to sleep a little better at night.
